Bitter Truths

279925_3jpg.jpg

To begin, from today’s Toronto Star

“The monks of Burma are poor, and they are unarmed, but they exert a life-and-death power over the population,” says Guy Horton, a British-based human rights consultant who has spent a decade collecting evidence of the Burmese military’s atrocities.

“This goes much deeper than ideology. The government has tried to buy off the monks by building temples and other things. But by attacking the monks they are putting their afterlives in grave danger,” says Horton, who is calling on Canada to join a campaign to bring the junta leaders to justice.

Monks normally begin the day by begging for food, and people who fill their bowls earn credits for the afterlife, known as karma. When monks reject food by overturning their bowls it puts the would-be donors in danger of a terrifying spiritual future.

“It’s a very high-pressure tactic,” explains Bruce Matthews, a Burma expert and professor emeritus of comparative religion at Acadia University in Nova Scotia. “It denies the military their credits. If they die without enough, their rebirth would be at a lower order of existence.”

The junta’s generals are heavily influenced by Buddhism, says Horton. “They’re terrified of the monkhood. They’re endlessly filming themselves going to the pagodas, and half of Burmese television is about the military bringing gifts there.”

I wrote recently that, no matter the outcome in Burma because of this current wave of protests, those that have employed nonviolent non-cooperation will achieve victory no matter the outcome simply because they refused to lower themselves to the level of those that they oppose. And I believe that to be very true. In fact, were it applied in more cases, such as in Gaza for example, we would very probably see a wave of change sweep the planet simply because only so many massacres can take place of innocents peacefully resisting before what we like to call ‘the civilized world’ would be forced to recognize the sheer magnitude of such a devotion and the utter brutality of those willing to confront it with violent means.

That said, and quite unfortunately given the Burmese military infrastructure, when one examines what is occurring in Burma from a realistic standpoint the truth is that for change to occur in an expedient fashion this event would have to have a significant impact on the officer corps within the Burmese military and lead to a dissention in the ranks that would ultimately threaten the Junta itself. Given the power wielded by Burma’s monks, and their refusal to accept alms, it is not out of the question that a movement within the military might choose to act.

Were that to occur, there are several outcomes to consider:

1) The current Junta would move immediately to purge its ranks, which, depending on the strength of those attempting to mutiny, might very well lead to a civil war. Such a state could also very well lead to ethnic guerrilla groups abandoning ceasefire agreements signed with the current government, adding a further level of chaos to the situation.

2) The Junta would simply be replaced by a more reasonable one bent on placating immediate foreign concerns, but one that would still not recognize the legitimacy of Aung San Suu Kyi.

3) That a faction within the military would depose the current regime and support the institution of Aung San Suu Kyi as the nation’s leader after securing Amnesty for themselves and positions within a reformed Burmese military establishment.

In the end, for this situation to come to a head, something will have to transpire within the ranks of the military itself. Were I a betting man, I would definitely say that that is a fact that isn’t lost on Burma’s Buddhist leadership, which may very well explain their heightened involvement in anti-government protests and their unwillingness to accept alms from members of the military.



Want to bookmark or share this entry?



This entry was posted on Saturday, September 29th, 2007 at 11:40 am. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.



3 Comments

  1. clarose098 Says:

    Agreed. The situation is not an easy one, its pushing many peoples boundaries. Hopefully, it ends for good of the people.

  2. karma Says:

    Foucault’s writings on power, knowledge, and discourse tell us that power is a fluid concept, circulating within a society, continually shifting. Power can take many different forms as we can see from the recent non-violent actions displayed by the Burmese monks. Too often people become blinded by overt displays of power (military actions, violent force, etc) and are not aware that they are capable of instigating change and opposing those forces that hold them down often while using an alternative, non-violent approach to empower themselves. Individuals acting collectively can impact the balance of power in any situation. I think you’re correct in saying that it’s too early to tell what the outcome will be in this instance. I believe, however, that the manner in which the monks of Burma have chosen to react to the military junta will lead to a power shift within the country, one that has been far too long in coming.

    PS I am relatively new to this forum so my apologies if I’m repeating anything that’s been discussed in the past. Also, just want to say thank you to all the authors and contributors here for wading through reams of (mis)information, distilling it down, and sharing with the rest of us. You bring a much-needed fresh perspective to issues we must all be more aware of. Thank you.

  3. Dale McShannock Says:

    It appears that a Japanese journalist was executed in recently while taking pictures of the demonstrations. The video of it is not the best, but one can see him getting pushed down and then shot. Japan is currently the largest donor of aid to Burma, i believe, so this incident might also lend some help to the situation.



Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.




By registering to comment you agree to adhere to website policies.