Here He Goes Again
Last night, during my performance in Thunder Bay, I ventured into unknown waters for the first time on this tour – I mentioned the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. The response was, as expected, muted, though I would learn after the performance from my soundman that people in the back of the theatre were deriding me for mentioning it and exclaiming that I should simply ‘shut up and sing’.
It’s here that I should mention that while broaching the subject of Canada’s role in Afghanistan I made perfectly clear my feelings regarding the separation of military service and policy, something that always seems to float straight over the heads of those that choose to disregard any debate on the subject out of hand. That said, no one in that theatre had the balls to say anything loud enough for me to hear in response, save one individual who claimed that there were certain things worth killing for. And while I disagree, I still commend him for having the guts to yell it out and state his opinion.
True, it’s a concert, and those in attendance have paid to hear me perform. Then again, if you’ve bought tickets to see George Carlin, you expect most of his show to be politically charged. Given what I spend the majority of my time on this website, and elsewhere, talking about, you’d think those who would willingly purchase tickets to one of my performances would at least think it a possibility that I might bring something up. And yet I am always surprised when people find it shocking that I do.
That said, the Burmese Junta has detained 4,000 monks and is planning on interning them in the far north of the country in an attempt to quell their role in recent protests. According to reports, they have been “disrobed and shackled”.
It’s important to remember that Burma’s monks did not resort to violent action in the recent protests, and in doing so have captured both the attention and imagination of the world in the process – ironically, even those that turn to violence as their favoured course of action. Of course, they cannot expect the cavalry to arrive, guns blazing, to secure their release and bring freedom to their country. Having said that, it’s of vital importance to point out that even though they have helped lead this latest charge against the current regime, they would not wish violence to be employed to see its downfall, nor their release, ensured. Many will, instead, go on hunger strikes and forfeit themselves, if need be, to continue their protest - but they will not advocate the use of violence.
There is something to be learned from the realization that only with the perception of greatness comes the arrogance of power and ultimately the need to ensure its continuity to protect the fragile shell of ego. To embrace the wisdom that power is, in truth, the drug of the weak, is to realize that the way to defeat it is to refuse to acknowledge it as anything but.
Want to bookmark or share this entry?
This entry was posted on Monday, October 1st, 2007 at 1:42 pm. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
October 1st, 2007 at 1:55 pm
Matt, I will be at the Buffalo show with 2 others and we strongly encourage you to speak about whatever is on your mind. Anyone with a “shut up and sing” attitude is not worthy of seeing you perform, in my opinion, and anyone coming to a show should be at least respectful, and at best, accepting of you as a whole person and not just an entertainer. I don’t mean to speak for anyone else but I would wager the majority of folks in any given crown are on the same page as you.
October 1st, 2007 at 2:14 pm
I was there, center in row D. As lame as this sounds, I wanted to scream out that you were my best friend. Thanks for pointing out so many aspects of our world that we fail to remember sometimes. The most memorable moment I’ve ever experienced at a concert is when you asked if people thought it would really be worth it in the end. The silence was wonderful realization.
Come back soon.
October 1st, 2007 at 2:20 pm
People are paying to see you, and your opinions are part of you. If they want to see someone who’s going to “shut up and sing” they can go see some shitty-ass bubble gum pop teenage band.
October 1st, 2007 at 2:22 pm
shut up and sing?? who’d they THINK they were going to see perform?? the fucking dixie chicks?? i mean COME ON…they buy tix to a MG show and expect you NOT to say anything?? especially with whats been going on in the world lately….i agree with KBryce….you should not only speak your mind, but do so more often in person…i would have loved if you had gone on a rant about these wars during your shows in Edmonton; not only because i agree with your position on the topic, but because your presence and message commands the attention of a room and your readers to maybe just MAYBE take a stance and say/do something about the world around them…..so im left to wonder: what kind of people would buy your music and/or tickets only to expect you to be the opposite of who you are when you get onstage? i know…the same people who buy Justin Timberlake’s music and say “i could give a shit about him, but i like his music…” well, to all those people out there who can identify with that sentence, fuck off and stay home! more MG for the rest of us who actually appreciate his ballsy-ness. heh. ballsy-ness lol.
October 1st, 2007 at 2:34 pm
“people in the back of the theatre were deriding me for mentioning it”
In the back…where they belong.
October 1st, 2007 at 2:49 pm
If you mention it tonight, I’ll be the guy in the front row who screams his approval.
October 1st, 2007 at 2:56 pm
Aren’t shutting up and singing mutually exclusive?
I believe that anyone has the responsibility of being aware of the current state of things in the world, and should not deride others for bringing them up. That is what being an informed citizen is about.
October 1st, 2007 at 2:58 pm
Looking forward to your Sarnia show. Saw you in London and enjoyed it. Hope you speak on some wordly topic. Always interested n what you have to say and right. I think the vast majority of people that go to your show expect some sort of comment from you. So to heck with the back row people. Rock on and comment away your fan base is benind you.
October 1st, 2007 at 3:06 pm
Almost every MG(B) show I’ve been to has some jackassery in the form of “shit up and sing”.
It seems to be related to the crowd that would rather watch the show from an assigned beer garden etc.
I was at the recent S’toon show, in which the venue was different this time around.
No booze, in a church, small venue. (2 out of 3 ain’t bad ;)
I don’t recall from the show that anyone there shouted out anything other than their song request of choice.
But why would you go to a show who’s artist entertains while reflecting on world events if all you want them to do is shut up and sing?
I don’t remember the last time I was shopping in a health food store and wondered where the fucking pizza pops were…
October 1st, 2007 at 3:11 pm
Don’t sweat the small shit Matt.
October 1st, 2007 at 3:14 pm
They wouldn’t let Muhammed Ali fight for speaking his mind and took away his title altogether….I wish we had more outspoken persons of popularity.
October 1st, 2007 at 3:15 pm
I totally respect the fact that you openly speak about your beliefs around issues that are considered ‘touchy’ to most.
I also think it’s hilarious when people assume you are an asshole because you do so.
October 1st, 2007 at 3:19 pm
Im from Thunder Bay, and I thought you played an awsome show the other night. I also think It’s good that you talk about things that should be discussed like the various wars that are going on right now. The shut up and sing comments just prove that people would rather be entertained then to talk and discuss things that actually effect each and every one of our lives. People keep thinking that because these problems do not directly effect them, they can just not care or pretened everything is ok. Things are far from ok we live in a pretty fucked up world, there is so much violence, crime, poverty, and hatered. An example is the ongoing wars in Israel and Palestine. There will never be any kind of change untill the past is forgotten, and we move forward before it is to late. Anyways I remeber something about freedom and what can be done about the situation the world is in at your concert in t.Bay and I found a quote, anyways thanks for the time.
“The most important kind of freedom is to be what you really are. You trade in your reality for a role. You trade in your sense for an act. You give up your ability to feel, and in exchange, put on a mask. There can’t be any large-scale revolution until there’s a personal revolution, on and individual level. It’s got to happen inside first. You can take away a man’s political freedom and you won’t hurt him- unless you take away his freedom to feel. That can destroy him. That kind of freedom can’t be granted. Nobody can win it for you.” - Jim Morrison
October 1st, 2007 at 3:20 pm
“shut up and sing” … WTF
IGNORANT in the truest sense of the word !
October 1st, 2007 at 3:27 pm
Matt, I went to the show last night and saw you for the first time. I was the “mayor’s kid” on the balcony you spotlighted. Ironically, my girlfriend and I are both serving members of the Canadian Forces. I don’t want to comment on the issue of Afghanistan (I’m obviously going to be bias), but I would like to thank you for distinguishing military service from policy. I’ve been a fan of yours for many years and really enjoyed the performance.
October 1st, 2007 at 3:37 pm
Why would being a member of the CF make you bias Scotty? I admit it would be outside of your lanes to comment on foreign policy as per QR& O’s but being a member of the CF doesn’t mean you should have a bias on the direction one way or the other.
Many CF members are pro the operation, many are not.
October 1st, 2007 at 3:37 pm
Can’t wait to see you at the Waterloo show, Matt. I’m there to hear you sing AND speak your mind. I’m glad someone out there shines light on these subjects because they do need to be brought to everyone’s attention. People like that think if we don’t talk about it, it’ll just go away. They’re sadly mistaken.
October 1st, 2007 at 3:46 pm
“shut up and sing” - that statement is so *condo*
BTW… the last sentence you wrote is too true. Thanks!
October 1st, 2007 at 3:55 pm
I was at the Thunder Bay show last night (2nd row, right up front) and I for one applaud you for speaking your piece and saying what you had to say. I applaud you just like I applauded your words last night. I would like to add that I do have the balls to say most anything to anyone but there comes a time when it’s better to shut up and just listen.
Further, I would like to apologize on behalf of the ignorant individuals in the back. It’s ignorance like that that is the root cause of these world problems in the first place.
Personally, I would buy a ticket just to hear you speak your mind on whatever you want. Hell, I’d buy two.
It’s a rare occasion to have the pleasure to hear an intelligent, educated and articulate individual speak in this red neck backwoods town.
Thank you for coming to our shitty little city.
Some people appreciated it.
F**k the ones that don’t.
October 1st, 2007 at 3:56 pm
Shut up and sing? Isn’t that why we have CDs and MP3 players? Part of the whole concert experience is to hear our what our favorite artists and bands have to say. They can have their own opinions on the wars, or lack there of, but that’s a little uncalled for, in my opinion.
October 1st, 2007 at 4:01 pm
on the ’shut up and sing’ business: Luckily it’s your name on the tickets, and your name on the signs, and you can say whatever the hell you want…you’re so much bigger than a handful of rude and unappreciative
‘fans’…I mean, if that’s what they want to call themselves after saying something like that…
on speaking about Iraq/Afghanistan: I think it takes tremendous courage when you’re anywhere in the public eye…good on ya for stepping out and talking about it.
On the Burma/Myanmar situation: I can’t believe that there have been that many monks detained…the Junta must be totally shitting themselves at the amount of world wide coverage this is getting…hopefully (and I know that the likelihood is slim, but…) hopefully there is a positive outcome to this.
Look alive!
It’s your day off tomorrow!!!:)
October 1st, 2007 at 4:04 pm
For those that choose to blatantly ignore what is happening in the world are not only ignorant, but irresponsible as well. It’s funny how the people you hear from the most regarding topics such as these generally have no idea what they are talking about anyway, and they would be the ones to say such slanderish remarks. Keep on speaking your mind Matt, the intelligent ones out there appreciate it…
October 1st, 2007 at 4:11 pm
its too bad that no one wanted to talk about it…clearly everyone has an opinion and an outspoken artist like matt is no different!, its good for public figures to talk about the horrible things that most people choose to ignore! im totally thinking about the dicks, assholes, and pussys speech from ‘team america’ right now!, haha!
i was at the 2nd show in vic and you talked about south park alot which im not really a fan of, im a family guy man myself! but you did mention good old gordon cambell and his dui!…and i was glad you talked about the album alot too!….whatever really….. it shouldnt be planned, its cool that you interact with the audience!….and come on thunder bay people who heckled!….how is the guy supposed to sing like that all the way straight through!….hes bound to get a little tired and parched!…..anyways, im out like a conservative at the gay pride parade!
hope the tour is still going strong!
October 1st, 2007 at 4:18 pm
Matt… I was at the Thunder Bay Show.. Ive Been at all of your thunder bay shows, i was sitting second row to your right hand side.. i loved what you had to talk about and hearing those people say shut up and play really agrivated me.. Two of my friends were killed in Afghanistan.. one of whom grew up 5 doors away from me my whole life… he was young, and had only two weeks left b4 coming home.. i even talked to him a week or two before he got killed Via msn.
Like my brother (IANB) and you said… i paid to come and see you.. not only did i pay to come and see you play, but I also paid to listen to your thoughts and opinions on current events (much like your other shows). I really appriciate you speaking up on current events and letting people know what you feel.
Thank you for an awesome night and i would gladly (like my brother said) pay to just hear you speak on current events..
again Matt thanks a lot for coming back to the bay I hope to see you again soon
p.s. nice microphone macro on flickr haha i just saw it like 5 minutes ago Kudos!
Ryan Benninghaus
October 1st, 2007 at 4:21 pm
I was actually suprised that there was no political commentary at the Winnipeg show. I kind of missed it.
October 1st, 2007 at 4:37 pm
As a fan who has seen too many MG (B) shows to count over the years, I have to say that one of my favourite parts of seeing Matt play live, particularly in the smaller venues, has always been having the opportunity to hear what he has to say. That’s also why I login to this blog everyday. His political commentary (plus the stand up comedy and the amazing music) is all part of the fantastic package that is Matthew Good Live.
Quoting Vegas Vic:
“Yeah but Matt, you aren’t Geo Carlin. I wasn’t at the show, but I do believe most of your fans are your fans due to your voice… the singing one… not necessarily the political one.”
Vic, if that is really the case, then I think it’s terribly sad…because those fans are seriously missing out. I think that the number of people who log in to this website everyday demonstrate that there certainly is an interest in Matt’s political voice as well.
p.s. daver, I love the Jim Morrison quote.
October 1st, 2007 at 4:41 pm
Gotta disagree with you Vegas. If people want someone to just sing and not be themselves, why pay for a concert? You can just stay and home and play the tunes. I admire you Matt for stating your beliefs and putting forth your reasons for them even when, or perhaps especially when, you know you’re not preaching to the choir.
October 1st, 2007 at 4:55 pm
Since half of my family has already spoken on this thread… I might as well pipe up too. Speak your mind! Politics is amazing that way, people have so many different opinions it makes it interesting, more so if they disagree. Stick to your convictions, whatever they might entail…
Enjoy my little city tonight, and if you sign an autograph for a bubbly redhead, give her a big hug for me! (my sister lol)
October 1st, 2007 at 4:57 pm
I’ll be at your Montreal show next week, and while I don’t always agree with what you say, I admire you for piping up, so keep on keeping on!
October 1st, 2007 at 5:08 pm
I was at the show — second row. While you were talking, I heard someone say “Are ya gonna sing???” and I thought it was pretty disrespectful. When talking to my friends after the show, they all agreed, and I mentioned that you should know by now what you’re getting into when you’re paying to see Matthew Good. But don’t let people like that stop you because, for what it’s worth, my friends and I all saw the speech portions of the show, political and otherwise, to be among the highlights. Thanks for returning to our city, singing, and speaking out.
-SM
October 1st, 2007 at 5:10 pm
On your solo acoustic tour last year in London, ON, someone near me quietly said “shut up and sing” and I said “shut up and learn” and my response was met with many people backing me up. So although there are a few in your audiences that would much prefer you didn’t bring that stuff up, I think there are far more who think the opposite.
It’s who you are, much of your music is framed around these issues you talk about. Like you said, people have to know what they’re getting when they buy a ticket to your shows.
October 1st, 2007 at 5:14 pm
Matt,
In defense of the “shut up and sing” people, perhaps they’d rather be entertained.
I know that George Carlin would be quite humourous with his political views.
I was not at the show, so I don’t know if you were serious, had pie-charts and such, or if you were joking about it.
I do recall seeing the Goo Goo Dolls last October (2006) at the Orpheum theatre and John Rzeznik went on a rant about Bush. Someone in the audience yelled “focus” and the rest of the crowd laughed and the band played on.
I think people would rather here humour than lecture. I’m not saying you lecture, I’ve never had the privilege to see you live. I don’t know how you approach the subject. I’m sure if you are funny, no one will care or deem it “shut up and sing” material.
Denis Leary is the only person I’ve heard rant and be hilarious about it.
How do you approach the subject?
October 1st, 2007 at 5:19 pm
I’ll be at the Buffalo show and it would make me curious if you didn’t speak your mind at various points during the show. I’m driving 3.5 hours to be there because I want to be there. If it was strictly a musical experience I was seeking I could listen to my CD. In my eyes, it’s a package deal. No one says I have to agree, disagree, support your opinions or participate in a debate. No one says you have to ’shut up and sing’. Following you for as many years as I have has reminded me that even though I’m not an ass kisser, I strongly respect you for what you do. Or perhaps it is the way you carry it out. Even so, of course I want to hear you sing, I’d be crazy to deny it. It’s your name on my ticket therefore I trust how you choose to share that time with us.
October 1st, 2007 at 5:27 pm
I love your speaking your mind, and laugh at someone complaining about not hearing “the hits”. Maybe have a “Sentimentally Pacifist” tour, if that isn’t too sarcastic. Don’t forget to thank war for giving you the right to denounce power, without being shot, in a public square, so that more can be silenced while wasting less bullets and slaves in the coffers of those that would hold power over you. I wonder why you choose to use your high and lighted stage to challenge dissent to your opinions? Tired of changing minds with subtlety?
Anyway, I think the monks marching the streets to fight for freedom and democracy is a very strong statement that war need not be fought with violence, but peace doesn’t truthfully exist beneath oppression, and the free(?) world that waits for you outside your door is provided largely by the blood of those that would not be peaceful (and eventually nonviolent) in the face of it. Please continue to be a beacon to those that would influence their expression for the sake of its consumers.
October 1st, 2007 at 5:30 pm
Shut up and sing??!! How about they shut up and listen? Bah.
As for the Burmese monks, sadly it looks as though the cavalry never did arrive -
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/worldnews.html?in_article_id=484903
I can’t wait to see you here in Vernon. I’ll bring my tazer just in case the back rows need some manners (I kid). Please speak your mind. We’ll be disappointed if you don’t.
October 1st, 2007 at 5:30 pm
I’ve always loved your music, but it is your thoughts and your politics that make me admire you. I, too, have had my voice stifled in the name of poltical correctness. There are few things so demeaning as being told that the thoughts that define you aren’t welcome. Your attitude and words help me to stay focused on the struggles I wage. I’ll be at the Halifax show next week and hope that you’ll be able to feel good about being as open as you wish that evening.
October 1st, 2007 at 5:33 pm
The greatest part about being a comedian is being able to vent anything you want and still keep a smile on peoples faces. In fact you can say almost anything you want as long as no-one really knows if you’re serious. This is a very great power entertainers can enjoy. I myself like to see people smiling when I am working. Just makes the day better. May calm, peace, love and beauty surround you.
October 1st, 2007 at 5:39 pm
I would say that anyone who is a fan of yours should be aware of your opinions, that you are known for your outspokenness, and therefore they should know going in that they may hear your opinions. If their not aware of your politics or your outspokenness, then they”re either pretty ignorant or they’re not fans.
I’d also challenge any of his “fans” who would tell him to shut up and sing to justify that position.
October 1st, 2007 at 5:40 pm
Unfortunately some people are always going to feel that way. It was my third MG show in Thunder Bay and you never fail to impress. Though I must say, around where I was (2nd row), “shut up and sing”ers seemed to be the minority. There are a lot of people who appreciate the commentary, especially when it’s insightful, which, unfortunately isn’t always the case when it comes to musicians speaking out during performances. A breath of fresh air, I think, along with another great performance.
October 1st, 2007 at 6:00 pm
Matt, I always remember listening to a concert you performed in Toronto, and one brief conversation you had with the crowd. It went something like this (I doubt you’ll remember, you likely get this alot):
I also remember a show you played at The Vibe in Peterborough (actually, I e-mailed you about this) about the crowd completely ignoring you while you were trying to tell a deeply moving story about a soldier-friend of yours. They were so loud, chatting away to themselves, that I could hardly hear you. It made me disgusted, and quite ashamed that people would act that way at a show.
If you enjoy and respect an artist enough to pay to see them perform, then you should attend to see them perform. This includes, but is not limited to, listening to their music, watching them play, listening to their banter, their stories, their gripes, their complaints, etc. If you don’t want to hear an artist speak their mind, then go merrily on your way listening to their CDs (or MP3s, as the case may be). Don’t ruin the experience for the artist (don’t you want them to keep making music, keep performing?) and don’t ruin it for everyone else in attendance that WANTS to hear what they have to say.
Sorry, just needed to rant about that for a bit =/
October 1st, 2007 at 6:16 pm
You’re experiencing this at your concerts and I just experienced that last night at a showing of “THE WAR ON DEMOCRACY’. I love this film and I hope the whole world sees it–after it was over there was roaring applause. The idea that was left ringing in our ears was that we must all keep our eyes open by continually striving to understand the war that is being waged on us and do what we can to fight it, from wherever we are, whatever our position . That being said, I’m disheartened by the fact that when someone, after the film was over, stood up and said to everyone…this shouldn’t end here, our own city (Vancouver)and province is also being sold right under our noses and we should go on to do something (i.e-this shouldn’t end with the viewing of the film and a short nod of the head agreeing that this was a good film)….no one, but a friend and I said “here, here” to this courageous guy. As if these few words had offended a group of people who not minutes earlier applauded a film that left them with similar ideas!
Also, of very important note. I have been attending much of the Vancouver International Film Festival. Yesterday, I found out that at least ten Chinese directors have been denied entry to Canada on temporary visas. This has also been the case with the Toronto film festival. This is directly related to a Canadian policy (not a Chinese policy but a Canadian policy) that is meant to discourage cross-cultural relations between China and Canada.
I found this out while watching a film entitled “Bing Ai” about a Chinese peasant woman who takes on the Chinese state, which is forcing her off her land in order to build a dam. When the announcer told us about the aforementioned policy and that because of this policy the film maker couldn’t attend the show, he suggested that we write our MLA and the Prime Minister, to which I quickly began to applaud (in hopes of getting a round of applause going, who, just like them, had heard this news for the first time). Only three or four other people began to applaud! Here we were, about to watch a film about a peasant who tried with every inch of herself to hold on to her land, fighting the state all the way….and almost the entire audience, in a comfy theater, couldn’t even muster up applause for the mere suggestion that we should talk to our own politicians about legislation that we should wholeheartedly be contesting! I spend most of my time reading books, watching films, listening to speakers, going to concerts and participating in conversation in order to learn from different people who, in the most eloquent of ways, remind us of the importance of standing up.
I find it more and more difficult to believe that anyone could buy into the bull-shit that our own political, economic, and social processes are out of our reach and that we can be “neutral”. As was pointed out in another excellent film (about Howard Zinn), ” You can’t be neutral on a moving train” .
October 1st, 2007 at 6:19 pm
Thank you for commenting on the monks.
October 1st, 2007 at 6:27 pm
I think it’s awesome when musicians talk with the audience instead of just playing. Your shows in the past have been that much better because you interact with the audience, involve us in the show. Some may not agree with your opinions, but if they’re any fan of yours, they should know this from your website. When you buy a Matt Good ticket, you don’t expect plain old music. You expect a comedy show, a funny story, and maybe for Matt to crack open a cold Heineken. It’s your show, you do what you want, and most of us love it. I think it’s awesome when you bring props (Ann Coulter doll, Paris Hilton book, etc.), tell stories, and entertain us between songs. The show goes on longer, which any Matt Good fan appreciates. I hope you keep it up, and talk about whatever you want, because when you come to London, I’ll be listening, laughing, and enjoying my favourite artist. It’s a treat seeing you perform live, Matt.
October 1st, 2007 at 6:38 pm
Oh, and I have one thing to add: “He died on stage! . . . . . kinda like me . . . . . ” ahaha….don’t be so hard on yourself, Matt!
October 1st, 2007 at 6:39 pm
“shut up and sing” doesn’t seem to rhyme with “nothing to hide” if you know what I mean.
October 1st, 2007 at 6:52 pm
I know I’ll be listening very closely when you play Sarnia. I may have to slap some folks up side the head (it’s Sarnia…there will be people bitching somewhere…), seen as I’ll be in the back row of the belcony, but I’ll be listening.
October 1st, 2007 at 7:00 pm
I remember when you were performing in Cape Breton and you mentioned the civilian death toll in Iraq. I’m not sure if you heard it, but two idiots in the back actually started cheering. I happen to have known those two idiots, and I assure you they weren’t cheering because you spoke your mind.
I’ve never understood peoples reaction to you when you speak out. It’s a MATT GOOD concert. If you even have the slightest interest in his music, it should be clear that any performance he gives is going to be politically changed. And for that matter, when has art even been free from politics? Satire is centuries old, and all modes of literature from poetry to prose contain innumerable politically charged essays and allegories.
Not to mention, when people ask you to “shut up and sing” are the contents of your lyrics flying over their heads? You’re hitting them with politics regardless.
(In case it wasn’t clear, thank you for speaking your mind and for introducing us to a great number of issues and perspectives that we would not have been privy to otherwise.)
October 1st, 2007 at 7:02 pm
Whether you sing, or speak of politics, I am there interested in seeing you for who you are. Be that, and nothing more.
Thank you Matt,
Dave
October 1st, 2007 at 7:36 pm
[quote comment="27813"]Whether you sing, or speak of politics, I am there interested in seeing you for who you are. Be that, and nothing more.
Thank you Matt,
Dave[/quote]
I agree with Dave, I couldn’t have said it better myself!
Thank you for being you!
October 1st, 2007 at 7:37 pm
I’ve said it before, and here it comes again:
Keep talking. Not only are you right, but hopefully over time the “Play Hello Time Bomb” crowd will thin out or grow up. That way the rest of us can enjoy you as you are. Not for what you were.
Things change….
October 1st, 2007 at 7:42 pm
Matt,
When you play in Ottawa on the 17th, I strongly encourage you to take some time to talk about any political issue(s) you feel you need to. As others have stated, I attend your shows not just to hear you sing/play but to spend time in a room with a man whom I have a great deal of respect for. I attend your shows for your views, your personality and your music.
That being said, there are those who are attending your shows only for the music. Chances are, these people will not understand/relate to your lyrics and are simply holding on from your MGB years. I still remember your show in Bala on the Avalanche tour very well. Never before had I been exposed to a crowd at a concert who were so disrespectful. I was actually embarrassed to be in that crowd (although I was separated as the minors got to sit in the awesome reserved section upstairs). I did enjoy the symbolism of you being on a higher level than that crowd, however, supplied by that odd, 10 foot high stage.
Ryan
October 1st, 2007 at 7:47 pm
I didn’t even make it there but it sounds like your fanbase would follow you off a bridge and may I politely recommend an international one?
I know the city well, it’s tight and we’ve lost a few of our own and I mean. Maybe it’s different in a giant city where every neighbour is another stranger in a silent lineup at a grocery or whatever they call them, health food stores, but here it’s kind of. Tight, small-town, like you said, people know each other, and we’ve lost locals in what feels like disproportionate numbers per capita.
Why it’s not so much shocking as nearly heartless:
Well for one there are a lot of connections to Minnesota, a lot of American flags everywhere to begin with, they’re friends and family, another is,
I wouldn’t have the guts to tell someone that their best friend or kid or brother or classmate teammate died in a pointless or evil war, even if they did.
I know it’s strange to have more respect for the dead than for the living and how much do I know to talk out of turn, I didn’t know any of the locals who died there but the thing is, they’re locals, they sell us groceries, lumber, do all the things that make a city and all you do is drive through to sing songs for a little while and you can’t even do that without reminding us of the fact that we lost locals to all this?
I’m pretty sure we knew of that, we have a newspaper, radios, schools, internet now, I don’t suppose any singer fresh off 1 61 or 11/17 is gonna change it with a song a blog and an uninvited speech, jog on.
How much connection to Ottawa or Toronto do you think this place has amuwau? There hasn’t been a Conservative elected in history from Kenora to Sault Ste. Marie, I’m pretty sure that makes us left-wingers. Canada’s revolution is going to come out of Winnipeg again if anywhere. I’m trying to think of precedent; all Jack White had to say was that it’s beautiful here and all Eddie Vedder had to say was thx for neighbourly help with Hurricane Katrina and all we said was yes it is and yeah anytime.
I’m glad it’s profitable, I really am. I mean if you’re begging for opinions and debate I hear that history is repetitive like your songs and maybe you just needed a band out there to help you pass the time c/o you’re old and washed up, so senile he couldn’t find the university, wound up at the auditorium, that’s what I heard.
So a true story about a local seagull then since they seem to be what YOU care about. My friend was tellin me they were huckin bread off the roof of a mill on lunch break - seagulls would swoop down, eat, trust, fight. They do this for a loaf of bread until buddy throws a giant bolt nearly as big as its body down. Seagull soars, eats the bolt, plummets, there. Same seagull, probably, they’re all the same.
Not a good story? Sometimes they’re caught with fishing rods. That one’s no good either? Hell maybe I should take up singing.
See if I’d have been there I’d have wanted to say all that but I would have said shut up and sing, loud, accent on the second word. All due respect though, they’re good songs.
To be clear that this isn’t hate mail I’m generally on the same page about this shit. Ain’t no Afghan ever called me a lazy drunk spearchuckin injun. Still stickin up for the theory that lives in Thunder Bay are amazingly more important to me than 4000 lives elsewhere including but not limited to wherever it is out west that folksingers come from.
I’m reminded of and recommending the end of In Dubious Battle by John Steinbeck.
October 1st, 2007 at 7:55 pm
hey matt
I was at the show in Thunder Bay when you mentioned the war.
Personally, I thought it was huge. I was so thankful that someone is gutsy enough to voice their oppinion when they have the chance. You had an auditorium of people hanging on to your every word, and i’m so glad you took advantage of that.
Its almost a relief that someone voiced their oppinion in a situation where their point would actually get across. Not everyone will listen to the “average Joe”. People look up to you and WILL listen to what you have to say. I would like to think that if I was in your possition, I would have done the same thing.
with that being said, I would like to leave on a thankful note. Thanks for voicing your oppinion and making your voice heard!
Keep talking! even if they are angered by what you are saying- people are still listening!
cheers!
October 1st, 2007 at 7:57 pm
Going on with rhiannonk’s comment (whom I sat with and discussed this very thing after the show with), the show was awesome Matt, and I’m really glad you brought up the war and such. It was refreshing in a way. I was quite happy that you did speak, especially since it was you. I think I would have left disappointed if you hadnt spoken briefly the way that you did. I share a lot of similar opinions, and have a lot of respect for you not only as a musician , but as a person. One thing I really like about being at your shows, is that you go by your own agenda and speak your mind, and it brings a more intimate feeling to the show.
As much as I love your music and I’m such a huge fan, I’d also love to hear you just talk and speak your mind on the issues of today.
Can’t wait for you to come back to t-bay :)
October 1st, 2007 at 8:00 pm
Can’t wait to see you in Ottawa, Matt.
October 1st, 2007 at 8:27 pm
[quote]There is something to be learned from the realization that only with the perception of greatness comes the arrogance of power and ultimately the need to ensure its continuity to protect the fragile shell of ego. To embrace the wisdom that power is, in truth, the drug of the weak, is to realize that the way to defeat it is to refuse to acknowledge it as anything but.[/quote]
Power is about creating the illusion of strength to control the actions of others. Strength is about being in control of ones actions, about taking responsibility.
You’re a good example of strength Matthew, don’t let anyone convince you otherwise.
October 1st, 2007 at 8:29 pm
I know you probably don’t read this far down in comments, you usually only read the first few, but anyway Matt…
I remember when you played up in Saskatoon here at Louis a year or so ago. (I didn’t go, wasn’t a fan then) Whoever wrote the event review in our campus newspaper did not exactly mention your political banter in a positive light. A lot of people have a ’shut up and sing’ mentality, tragically.
October 1st, 2007 at 8:32 pm
[quote comment="27821"]Can’t wait to see you in Ottawa, Matt.[/quote]
Same! The Ottawa show is coming up and I want to hear something really controversial come out of your mouth! haha Seriously, this business with shut up and sing is trite rubbish, tell them to shut up and leave! haha what kind of people make comments like that? Anyway, see you on stage soon, the two Erik(c)’s of Ottawa will be cheering you on.
October 1st, 2007 at 8:36 pm
Baaa and that’s exactly why you have to invent some sort of booby-trap for those who sit at the back of the theatre. I envision some sort of toilet-plunger contraption hidden, naturally, in those soft red cushy seats. At the tap of a button (or sip of wine, whatever floats your boat), the said plunger will launch at warp-speed up unmentionable sphincters.
Man, I have to patent this shit.
October 1st, 2007 at 8:41 pm
To be honest, I was really surprised when you didn’t say anything (political, that is) at the Winnipeg show. It didn’t make me happy or unhappy, I was just happy to be there to listen to whatever you have to say or sing. Those people really aren’t in it for the whole package so whatever, sucks to be them.
October 1st, 2007 at 8:42 pm
quoted by Daver: “The most important kind of freedom is to be what you really are. You trade in your reality for a role. You trade in your sense for an act. You give up your ability to feel, and in exchange, put on a mask. There can’t be any large-scale revolution until there’s a personal revolution, on and individual level. It’s got to happen inside first. You can take away a man’s political freedom and you won’t hurt him- unless you take away his freedom to feel. That can destroy him. That kind of freedom can’t be granted. Nobody can win it for you.” - Jim Morrison
Here here Jimbo. Thanks Dave for posting that… And the things people believe about the poet, just anger me… right, that’s a different topic though……
I wonder if MG has ever played a Doors cover………. OMG that would friggin rock….
October 1st, 2007 at 8:48 pm
Right, my two cents:
I was expecting you to bring up alot of politics topics, I can’t believe anyone would be shocked to hear you talk about the things you have true passion for….. I am wondering if there will be a highly political album anytime soon?
October 1st, 2007 at 8:48 pm
That last paragraph is quote worthy, to be sure.
October 1st, 2007 at 8:50 pm
…fuck ‘em if they can’t take a joke.
Gutless wonders of the world, who probably have the attention spans of rubber boots and bore easily. You should’ve farted or shot an elastic in their eye…that probably would’ve entertained them. I can only imagine what their conversations include. If they don’t have the courage to speak out with conviction then I’m quite sure that they should just learn to “shut up and listen” when the topic is one of such importance. They might even learn something (hell, I have). It’s only the state of the world and our future that’s at stake and being discussed. But “damn it, we didn’t come here for that, we wanna hear Strange Days!”.
The bozos do come out of the woodwork for concerts, don’t they? There were some in the audience in Vancouver who thought it would be a good time to discuss how drunk they got the night before during my favorite song. And the song after. Apparently it was quite funny. To them.
October 1st, 2007 at 8:51 pm
Dale, good point… how does he go about Trademarking that? That’s pretty amazing what he wrote.
October 1st, 2007 at 8:56 pm
ha ha, I was at that show, I yelled something, you or your sound man must not have heard it, I yelled (this is a longer form) that the men in Afghanistan are there doing a good service, though the government’s intentions behind it are wrong. (so mixed intentions almost) and amazin show Matt, what kind of guitar(s) were you using? (I had bad seats) and I’m very glad you didn’t just (to quote that dick-head) ” just shut up and sing” hope to see you play again really soon!
October 1st, 2007 at 9:01 pm
Deb, had no idea you had a shitty time during the concert… I demand a re-concert MG.. “Start over” please and thank you. Who was the genius that said that anyways? Awesome
October 1st, 2007 at 9:02 pm
and about the heavily political album, Matt Good (to me atleast) is the Neil Young of the far west. He IS political in a lot of his music.
October 1st, 2007 at 9:50 pm
I dont think you should shut up and sing. I think you should do what you feel like doing, afterall most people probably appreciate political conversation coming from you, this is your show (slash) tour, I would hope to hear some in Ottawa.
October 1st, 2007 at 10:00 pm
I think we all have the ability, the right, and perhaps the duty to say the things not only that we think, but also the ones that we feel. Some people would have you believe that mathematics is the universal languge, though I see that as no different than any other language in that it is inadequate to describe or measure what we seek to. What binds is the language of emotion- not only what we think and quanitfy, but what we qualify as well- what it is that we know. I think it is through this that we are able to find commonalities and connect to all other things, including people. However, none of us come in the parts that we would have ourselves believe- we are not as cleanly cut up as we would like ourselves or other people to be, or at all; though, we continue to attempt to quantify and measure one another anyway.
I think when people buy a ticket to see an artist, buy their art, or any creation as well as expose themselves to their ideas and even every day people that they meet that they might think they are able to experience these things of the artists or people as seperate from the actual person and even from themselves, but no amount of stage lighting, dark paint, or obscure symbolism is going to hide the artist within the creation as a whole being and should someone pay attention, they might see them surface instead of being so self centered as to think that the connections are not there and that they’re all individuals (even though they somehow end up in the same place at the same time for the same reason doing the same thing and feeling the same emotions?). People truly baffle me at times. Are all of these thoughts and emotions that you would feel about human life, war, Afghanistan, Iraq, etc. not embedded rather clearly within your art anyway?
I don’t think we choose what we share with people in that we are always sharing our whole selves with them in what we’re saying- always telling people who we are. What we choose is what we allow ourselves to see- in ourselves and in others. I say, tell people what you feel, what you think and as long as you do so honestly- let them sort through their own blindness and myopia. It may be their own expression to you, however, that that is who or what they are. Perhaps some day they’ll take heed of their own advice, shut up, and start singing. it would be interesting to see if anyone bought a ticket to their show. ( :
October 1st, 2007 at 10:12 pm
This is the best thread for discourse that we’ve had in a while. Didn’t say anything at tonight’s show, it was at a bar on a small campus, perhaps I should have.
October 1st, 2007 at 10:36 pm
cheers to you
October 1st, 2007 at 10:46 pm
Just got home from seeing you play in Sault Ste Maire. You were awesome as usual. I loved it! Only complaint I do have is that you didnt mention the war and comment on the current political situations. As others have mentioned, I did expect you to incorporate it into your show more. However, hearing you only sing is hardly a negative! Thanks for the autographs and the great night of magnificent music.
October 1st, 2007 at 11:17 pm
Matthew, I just read this thread and gee, you got a lot of loyal fans! Sounds like your tour is doing well. Congrats.
Now, if you think you got some jerks in the audience, I gotta tell ya, I just read a story about Springsteen and the E Street Band. Unbelievable amount of hate and insults being tossed at them! It’s sad, but I guess it goes with the territory. Take heart that 99.9 are there for a good time and will enjoy themselves one way or the other. Back in the 60’s , I played bars down south that had chicken wire around the stage to keep beer bottles from hitting you. That wasn’t just in the movies!
October 1st, 2007 at 11:29 pm
I was actually disappointed that you stayed mostly away from political topics at the shows I attended.
October 2nd, 2007 at 12:42 am
your fan base has a weird dynamic…it amazes me really.
October 2nd, 2007 at 1:10 am
Keep talking hard…
October 2nd, 2007 at 1:20 am
Hopefully our crowd in Buffalo will be more accepting and open minded to a much needed education.
October 2nd, 2007 at 3:36 am
I was wondering why you didn’t say anything of the sort in the Sault. The show was amazing. Thanks so much for coming here once again.
October 2nd, 2007 at 3:50 am
[quote comment="27813"]Whether you sing, or speak of politics, I am there interested in seeing you for who you are. Be that, and nothing more.
Thank you Matt,
Dave[/quote]
Dave- you couldn’t have said it more simply- You’re so right…Matthew, those who truly care, go to see you for who you are, what you have to say and to enjoy what it is all about. To me and to many- it is the only way to interact with you at some sort of intimate level- whether it is hearing you beautiful voice or trying to get inside that vast headspace of yours… Listening and learning is what we go for…fuck everyone else…(sorry people- but if you don’t wanna hear it all- the good with the bad- then stay at home…it’s called freedom of speach and he is on the stage, not you.- so shut uo and listen).
muah, L
October 2nd, 2007 at 4:10 am
In the immortal words of Ash here’s what I would’ve said:
“Ok you Primitive Screwheads, listen up! You see this? This… is my boomstick! The 12-gauge double-barreled Remington. S-Mart’s top of the line. You can find this in the sporting goods department. That’s right, this sweet baby was made in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Retails for about $109.95. It’s got a walnut stock, cobalt blue steel, and a hair trigger. That’s right. Shop smart. Shop S-Mart. YOU GOT THAT?!?Now I swear, the next one of you primates who even touches me. I’ll kill you! Oh you little bastards! All right, I’ll crush each and every last one of ya! I’ll squash you so hard you’ll have to look down to look up!”
Yeah maybe i’d say that…and maybe i’m a chinese jet pilot.
Hail to the king, baby
October 2nd, 2007 at 5:16 am
I definitly want you to say what you want.
I remember the …
Matt: “Go Leafs Go!”
Crowd: *cheers*
Matt; “Just as I fucking thought…”
… incident but I remember that I couldn’t hear what you said before that. I knew it must have been important, I knew it must have been political and I felt bad I couldn’t hear because too many boobs were talking, Matt didn’t speak clearly or I’ve spent too many years infront of speakers at concerts.
Also the demographic of fans is rather odd. I don’t pretend to know a lot about politics… and I find the topic intimidating but there’s just some things that people should give a damn about and thanks to Matt I am sure some of us here have wider eyes.
October 2nd, 2007 at 5:28 am
[quote comment="27824"][quote comment="27821"]Can’t wait to see you in Ottawa, Matt.[/quote]
Same! The Ottawa show is coming up and I want to hear something really controversial come out of your mouth! haha Seriously, this business with shut up and sing is trite rubbish, tell them to shut up and leave! haha what kind of people make comments like that? Anyway, see you on stage soon, the two Erik(c)’s of Ottawa will be cheering you on.[/quote]
And Michelle, too.
What kind of people make comments like that? Not real Matt Good fans. Perhaps guests of real Matt Good fans. Or Rico fans. Or devil worshippers, waiting for the rollerskates song. Or Chinese jet pilots. Or Merle.
I don’t know anyone smart enough to buy tickets to Matt Good but stupid enough to shout something like that.
(This comment was not intended to offend any Chinese jet pilots.)
October 2nd, 2007 at 5:37 am
Holy shit….again some concert goer’s obviously have no idea who you are or what you are about!!!
You are an artist, a poet, a writer, and activist…free speech at your show is expected from your fans! The gutless will mutter thier words, yet… always you stand tall in the face or such ignorance!
I am not surpised by people’s reactions…but totally reved to see your show in Geulph…front row! Speak your mind…I expect it!
P.S. I am hoping to find the article I wrote to a local Newspaper about 8 years ago (Salmon festival in GFW) about you and free speech and I will post it or bring it to the show!
October 2nd, 2007 at 5:43 am
[quote comment="27758"]Matt, I will be at the Buffalo show with 2 others and we strongly encourage you to speak about whatever is on your mind. Anyone with a “shut up and sing” attitude is not worthy of seeing you perform, in my opinion, and anyone coming to a show should be at least respectful, and at best, accepting of you as a whole person and not just an entertainer. I don’t mean to speak for anyone else but I would wager the majority of folks in any given crown are on the same page as you.[/quote]
I agreed and will also be in Buffalo with three others who are all travelling a distance not only to hear your music but respect that it springs forth from your convictions.
October 2nd, 2007 at 5:45 am
[quote comment="27758"]Matt, I will be at the Buffalo show with 2 others and we strongly encourage you to speak about whatever is on your mind. Anyone with a “shut up and sing” attitude is not worthy of seeing you perform, in my opinion, and anyone coming to a show should be at least respectful, and at best, accepting of you as a whole person and not just an entertainer. I don’t mean to speak for anyone else but I would wager the majority of folks in any given crown are on the same page as you.[/quote]
October 2nd, 2007 at 6:34 am
Matt, yes it is your show and you can say what you want and most of your fans are aware of your political views (that’s why some are fans). You must accept, unfortunately, that some of your so called fans are just fans because it is cool and they are not aware or concerned about your views in your music as well as your comments in one of your concerts. These people probably have no clue what your lyrics are for example or they have completely failed to find or look for any message that you might have. I only hope that they are a very small percentage of your overall intelligent fan base. You are a leader, and perhaps these people that were stunned at your concert will reflect on your comments and look into what is going on in the world around them. They may one day realize that almost every U.S. military base in Afganistan is on a path that follows perfectly with one of the biggest oil pipelines in the world. My career has taken me all over this world - working for the U.N, NATO, and 6 of the world’s largest military powers - all as a civilian. I am both disgusted and alarmed with the current state of the planet’s well being. Your music (and words at your concert) are badly needed to get these people out of the haze that they have been put into. Please do not stop doing what you feel you must - that’s is all I ask you as a huge fan.
October 2nd, 2007 at 6:45 am
Some fans (me for instance) came to your music BECAUSE of your views. Keep on talkin’, Matt.
October 2nd, 2007 at 6:53 am
At the risk of sounding like a complete Devil’s Advocate, I simply have to believe that people such as those who routinely visit this website and actually have an idea of what Matthew Good is about aside from the music, are a distinct minority at one of his concerts. I know 10 people, including myself, who will be attending the show in Halifax, and I can safely say that I’m the only one of the 10 who knows of Matt’s political orientation, his ongoing battle with Bi-Polarity or his eye-opening divorce. That’s 10% of my small market sample. That leaves 90% who simply want to hear a guy and his guitar sing songs that they’re familiar with. It seems outrageously realistic to me to understand that there will be many concert goes thinking “Shut up and sing” even if they’re not bold enough to say it.
Obviously, the musical talent and track record are what’s going to bring MOST of the people to the show. Rightly or wrongly, the “lecture” part is only going to appeal to the few.
In no way am I suggesting that Matt resist being himself. After all, this is the “Nothing to Hide” tour and hearing Matt speak instead of reading him is partly of why I’m going in addition to the music which is, of course, the foundation of me being a fan. I simply think readers have to be more realistically about who is standing next to them at a Matt Good show.
October 2nd, 2007 at 7:12 am
Of course we are all entitiled to our political opinion, but I’m going to have to agree with Matt. I mean, given the amount of blog material that is written specifically about Afghanistan and Iraq, not to mention Matt’s outspoken views on politics most of of his career ( I say most as I am 21, and was not into the older stuff when I was 9). My biggest concern is, why are musicians different from the common man/ woman? I remember the big uproar about Eminem’s “Mosh” during the 2004 US Presidential Elections. Regardless of a persons occupation, one should not be expected to supress his or her opinions- whether they be on hot dogs or Canadian Foreign Policy. Should we begin to expect that of those who do not agree with us, we are just as terrible as any dictator supressing the human rights of his or her country.
Not that you need my or anyone else’s permission, but keep it up Matt. I think the point that some fans may be missing, is that by writing these blogs, you are giving many young people a chance to experience healthy debate and a chance to perhaps spark an interest in something other than video games and one’s everyday life whether than meaning human rights issues worldwide, conflicts and wars that effect nearly every aspect of our lifes and many others across the globe, or an appreciation of music and all it has to offer. Just because you are a musician does not mean you regard yourself only with your music projects and touring. It is silly even to think such a thing. Would any Britney fan attend on of hr concerts and tell her to stop dancing in her sexually suggestive fashion and just sing? No, well one because she cannot in recent years, and two, because you are buying the show, the experience which I find to be much more influencial on young people, sadly enough.
Keep doing what you are doing; its never going to be easy, I’m sure you already are aware of that, but for those who appreciate a fellow Canadian speaking out about what he believes to be important, well, you must know what that can mean for another person.
Cannot wait for the show in Brandon, I’ll be front row and listening attentively.
October 2nd, 2007 at 7:14 am
In re-reading my comment after the editing period had passed, I would like to apologize for using the incorrect term “Bi-Polarity” instead of “Bipolar Disorder”. “Bi-Polarity” sounds scientific as if it has something to do with magnets. It would be likened to Matt having an affliction where he both attracts and repels at the same time, which ironically and keeping with the topic, is probably what happens to a crowd at a Matt Good concert, when he starts to talk politics.
October 2nd, 2007 at 7:30 am
Come to think of it, “Bi-Polarity: The concept of simultaneous attraction and repelling” might be a solid explanation for my history with the opposite sex…..hmmmm…..interesting.
Sorry for taking up so much space, both here and on the planet.
October 2nd, 2007 at 8:59 am
The evening started fucked up with you not being able to hear your guitar during
99% but that I think got you kinda chatty and I loved the whole interaction in Thunder Bay I was in the front row and at times disappointed wiht those in the rear of the theatre ( last minute tickets - maybe he’ll play automatic etc )
The new album translates so well in concert a nd I was eagerly anticipating an evening of new material AND politics. I was not dissapointed. I really enjoyed the fact you changed the set list to do advertising on police cars. I got a copy of the set and noted we missed fated and metal airplanes but it was a good trade. Your war discussion was for me as important to hear as any song given this is what
I come to think of as a Matt Good experience. I am also a Physician and was quite
happy to hear your take on mental health… very brave to speak out about it and
given the tone of your recent album some levity was very cool of you.
I can’t wait until the next time you are in Thunder Bay - a large number of fans here thought it was awesome!
October 2nd, 2007 at 9:14 am
After reading so many other people’s messages of support, most of which are bound to be more eloquent than mine, I just couldn’t help adding to them even if no one reads down this far:
Matt, please never stop speaking out on the issues you care about. Its part of what makes you a much better citizen of this world than most of us. Even if every single person in the crowd or on the planet demands that you shut up. Doing the right thing seems to often involve going counter to the flow. My Dad once told me that if most people approve of what you are doing, then its probably not the right thing to do. The longer I spend in our world, the more I agree with him. Although I’ve never had the privilege of meeting you, I have a bottomless amount of respect for your honesty, openness and courage. So never give up Matthew, stay yourself and nothing less.
October 2nd, 2007 at 9:34 am
I just wanted to add that although I’ve never had the privilege of meeting you Matt, I have a bottomless amount of respect for the honesty, openness and courage you consistently display. Thank you for being a beacon of light and letting us glimpse the kind of integrity we should all be aspiring to.
October 2nd, 2007 at 10:31 am
Perhaps you should do some sort of double tour. First you can cross the country in your ‘Shut Up and Sing’ tour for all the idiots out there who are scared of learning something outside of a school setting. Once you get to PEI, you turn around and start your ‘Shut Up and Learn’ tour, making all the same stops in reverse order. The posters for the second tour could have a disclaimer saying, “Warning: By purchasing tickets for this show, you acknowledge and accept the risk that you may hear something you disagree with. Neither Matt Good nor the organizers of this event may be held legally accountable for individuals who learn during the course of the show.”
The best part is that for the first tour, you don’t even necessarily need to show up. Just sort of set a paper mache dummy of yourself on a chair with a guitar, hit ‘play’ on the CD player, and go out to the bar. We can go get drunk and talk politics!
October 2nd, 2007 at 11:09 am
In the case of most bands/performers I am of the “shut up and sing” opinion (although aware that shutting up and singing at the same time is an impossibility) but that is only because most performers don’t dedicate time and energy to any cause beyond an occassional utterance at shows or to gain some press coverage during TV time - the majority aren’t truly devoted to the causes they proclaim they are. However, in your case Matt, even a glance at your web-site should remove all doubt as to the importance you place on national and international events and your dedication to spreading your thoughts about the injustices occurring around the globe.
Of course I would rather hear you sing than talk but that is only because you are a masterful singer/songwriter, not because I think you have nothing important and meaningful to say. See you in Buffalo - whether you sing or not.
October 2nd, 2007 at 11:25 am
[quote comment="27881"]Of course I would rather hear you sing than talk but that is only because you are a masterful singer/songwriter, not because I think you have nothing important and meaningful to say. See you in Buffalo - whether you sing or not.[/quote]
Actually I think two hours of Matt talking would be just as entertaining (you can hear him sing anytime). Matt, you should do some monologues!!!
October 2nd, 2007 at 11:25 am
That sort of ignorance is so discouraging.
Keep sharing what you have to say, Matt - singing or speaking.
October 2nd, 2007 at 2:21 pm
[quote comment="27872"] ( I say most as I am 21, and was not into the older stuff when I was 9).[/quote]
Wow I feel really effin old all of a sudden. I knew I left West Man for a reason.
October 2nd, 2007 at 2:23 pm
I’ll bet the dingleberries that said “shut up and sing” are the same tools who sit and have a chat while at a concert. I think it’s less about being assoholic and more about the intentional apathy a lot of the newer generations seem to cling to like a life raft. Not only has it led them down a road that will take them nowhere, they are becoming more and more ignorant. These are the same people who laugh at kids in school for reading a book, or enjoying classes. Yet, the kids who read, and go to class tend to end up being the productive members of society. These puss bags probably have only heard your music on the radio, gone out and bought a cd(probably giving them more credit than is due), and that is the limit of their exploration. Any more and their brains might overload from actually learning something. Imagine.
I love what you do, and I hope we get to hear some of what you think in Toronto or Hamilton. Keep fighting the good fight pally, cause if we all give up, we all fall down.
October 2nd, 2007 at 3:57 pm
Matt, you get the last laugh… that dude had to pay to get in.
October 2nd, 2007 at 5:46 pm
I was also at your Thunder Bay show…first of all, I want to say that I really enjoyed it, you sounded great. When those people in the back yelled, my friends and I were angry and spent the way home talking about how ignorant and rude some people can be. You seemed to be very informed about politics, and although I don’t feel as informed as you are, I agreed with the basis of your points, and I couldn’t have said it better myself. I have always been a fan, but before the show, I visited this website and I was pleased to read about your interest in politics. I had a feeling that some of these issues may be brought up at your show, and i was looking forward to hearing your take on the political issues we are undeniably facing. As an artist I appreciate your political voice…I feel anyone who has the ability to make people listen should recognize what is going on right now. I was very impressed with your show and I think you are brilliant. Thanks for doing what you do, and being an inspiration to us all.
October 2nd, 2007 at 7:00 pm
Personally, I enjoy the idea of a musician who can speak politics without simply walking up to the microphone and shouting “Fuck Bush! I hate Bush!” for the sake of a cheap response from the audience. Yes, most Canadians hate Bush and will cheer when you say that, but it is nothing insightful and making people cheer is no difficult feat. What I love about Matt is that his idea of a political discussion isn’t merely “Canada rulz #1!” He will actually keep up on the news, learn about ongoing global events that he thinks are significant, and share his opinion on the matter. The problem with most debates today is that the majority of people will do the last part (sharing of opinion) without going through the trouble of informing themselves. And worse yet, these are often the sort of people who believe their opinions to be the only ones allowed.
I will be the first to admit that I’m not nearly as informed about politics and global events as I should be, but that is why when the topic is brought up, I am far more likely to listen, rather than say something uninformed (the mistake of the masses). It sounds kind of sad, but Matt and this site are actually what has gotten me slightly more interested in the world around me, and this is now my main source of what is going on. If a topic on this site interests me, I will seek out more information about it.
So, to sum up this entry (and contribute something more serious than my last post), feel free to discuss politics all you like at the Fredericton show. If it wasn’t for your discussions, I probably would be far more ignorant than I am.
October 2nd, 2007 at 7:27 pm
Denial is a wonderful thing, isn’t it? I have only been a fan for about 6 years (I’ve only known of you that long), and I’ve been hearing all those shitty comments that whole time, and frankly, I don’t understand it. The second I went to see you play (in Vancouver), there were 2 girls in line in front of me. Another came running out from the side of the building “Matt is in the back signing autographs!” One of the girls says to the other, “Fuck him, he’s an asshole.” They looked at each other, then proceeded to RUN to the back of the building. The guy and his girlfriend that I had been talking to in line just laughed because I looked so shocked. I guess because I still don’t understand how people that don’t know you can act like they do enough to say those things. Shut up and sing???? Seriously???? I think they should just shut up and go see Nickleback, or Justin Timberlake or some such shit. I have learned more about what is going on in the world from your blog than I have from the severely edited version of the U.S. news sources, and appreciate the fact that you give your opinion, and give your fans an opportunity to voice their opinions in this blog. So keep up the great work, and since you ARE the devil, you can pretty much do what you want anyway, right?
Matt Good concert ticket - $45.00
Roundtrip plane tickets from California to Vancouver - $350.00
Airport shuttles - $100.00
Merchandise - $150.00
Hotels - $200.00
Matt Good “witty banter” priceless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Worth every damn penny!!!!!
October 2nd, 2007 at 10:02 pm
I’m getting a bit annoyed at all the comments stating “fans of Matt Good should know well enough what they are getting into when they go see one of his concerts”. I couldn’t disagree more. Not everyone that buys his albums and goes to his concerts sit and read the posts on this website. Many people are casual fans. I, for one, am not one of these people, but I know many fans of radio rock that aren’t internet regulars, so how would they know, and why should they be EXPECTED to know?
It’s a fine line that an artist walks between giving the fans what they pay for and freedom of artistic expression. I absolutely do NOT agree that artists such as Matt should be thought of as circus monkeys that are there to do a trick for them, the “shut up and sing” mentality, but at the same time, it has to be expected on some level that there will be people at shows that are there to hear the singer sing, not talk about his own personal political agenda. Not saying it’s right, just pointing it out.
I am not a fan of pre-packaged freeze dried artists such as Nickleback, Default, etc, but just because you think they suck doesn’t mean they don’t have a valuable opinion. I have my views on the state of the ever-dying musical landscape in North America, but it isn’t necessary to take potshots at other bands. They just know their target audience, and that 99% of the 12 year old girls in attendance would just end up cocking their heads wondering who this guy “dubya” Chad Kroeger is talking about.
Maybe Matt’s tickets should read “an evening of music and political discussion”. Maybe the damn shows wouldn’t have sold out so quick, and I would have been at the Winnipeg show. And why wasn’t a second date added? I’d go to the Brandon show, but it’s during the week!!! DAMMIT.
And another thing, is there anyone else in these posts that actually speak their minds instead of constantly fighting for Matt’s undying affections? Speak your minds people, I’m sure even Matt gets a bit tired of reading how much people love him.
October 2nd, 2007 at 10:20 pm
maybe if more public figures would stop singing and start talking,the world could start moving in a better direction.
October 3rd, 2007 at 12:46 am
[quoting Palonious)
And another thing, is there anyone else in these posts that actually speak their minds instead of constantly fighting for Matt's undying affections? Speak your minds people, I'm sure even Matt gets a bit tired of reading how much people love him.[/quote]
Again, someone who thinks they “know” what Matt is thinking. Obviously, you are NOT reading what the rest of are writing (sorry, not trying to speak for anyone, but…..) because if you were, you would know while we appreciate Matt’s opinions and outlook on certain things, there are plenty of fans who don’t agree with everything he says. Most of us will also never meet him, so really, does it matter what we post here? To you? As I recall, this is Matt Good’s blog, so when he is tired of us adoring him or whatever, he’ll probably say so, or at least close the blog.
If you don’t want to hear him talk, don’t go to the shows. Leave the tickets for those who do.