What’s Eating Gilbert
Tuesday, June 5th, 2007There’s an old adage – boys will be boys. There’s another old adage – we are products of our environment.
Take for example a recent incident in Gilbert, Arizona. A local parent reported that her son’s yearbook contained bomb threats, one signed by a boy named David and the other by an Iraqi-American boy named Mustafa Abdul Razzaq. After the parent notified authorities, the school was evacuated and the Gilbert police telephoned the Razzaq residence to determine if Mustafa was there, which he was. It being a half day, he had decided not to attend.
In reality, what had occurred was that the comment in the yearbook in question was never written, nor signed, by Mustafa. It had been penned by two other boys who later admitted to it and were taken into custody. The threat was, of course, not real, and the two youths, one 13 and one 14, had charges filed against them.
From the local paper, The Tribune…
“Mustafa, his mother and police discussed the incident in interviews with the Tribune.
The teen and his family call it a religious bias incident that was one of many over the years that have targeted the boy because he is a Muslim. Police say it was just a prank that had unfortunate consequences.”
[…]
“Since the deadly attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, they say this is just one of many times that Mustafa’s classmates have labeled him a terrorist. He says kids have told him to “go hijack a plane and run into a building” verbally and on notes they’ve left on his desk.
Sometimes he’d retaliate and get suspended. Sometimes, he’d ignore them.
But because the whole school was evacuated last week, he’s afraid to return there. He says he’s been getting phone calls and text messages from kids asking if he is guilty even though he’s been cleared by police.
Mustafa is upset with the school.
“Some of the teachers in the junior high don’t care,” Mustafa says of the discriminatory teasing he’s endured. “They don’t want to get into this kind of stuff. That’s why I don’t like Mesquite Junior High School that much.”
Mohammed AbuHannoud, the civil rights director for the Arizona chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, says his organization hears these types of complaints all the time.
“I think Mustafa is an example of what’s going on here after Sept. 11 with a lot of Muslim families,” AbuHannoud says. “I get so many calls, for example, from other parents and they complain, ‘My son is called Saddam, or a classmate called my son Hussein or Saddam Hussein.’ The schools do not do anything serious against that.”
Gilbert police spokesman Sgt. Andrew Duncan says the department is “sympathetic to the serious psychological effects of bias-motivated crimes,” but in this instance, police found the two students meant it as a joke.
Even so, the department took the hoax seriously and submitted juvenile referrals for each boy on charges of interfering with an educational institution, threatening and intimidating, and threatening to damage the school.
On Wednesday night, no one answered the phone at the home of the boy who wrote about Mustafa in the yearbook.
Dianne Bowers, a spokeswoman for the Gilbert Unified School District, says Mustafa’s mother had not contacted the school to report race- or religion-related bias incidents.
However, Bowers tried to address these concerns Wednesday by arranging an appointment for Abdulghafoor to meet with the school’s diversity officer. She also said the school strives to promote tolerance through its Character Counts program, which encourages trustworthiness, respect, responsibility, fairness and citizenship.
Abdulghafoor says she has been in touch with school officials and is disappointed with the lack of response.
She said the first religious bias incident occurred in 2001. Mustafa was in second grade, and one day, her husband got a call from FBI agents. They told him the school had called the bureau after a teacher overheard Mustafa call himself Osama bin Laden. Later, his mother said he told them that kids at school had been calling him by the terrorist’s name.
The FBI could not immediately verify the 2001 incident, but the bureau’s Arizona spokeswoman, Deborah Mc-Carley, says the family’s story sounds plausible. After Sept. 11, any complaints referring to terrorism had to be assessed and taken seriously.
Another incident occurred last year, Mustafa says. He was made fun of when he came to school dressed in traditional Saudi Arabian garb for a class assignment - each student was to come to school representing a different country.
“They tell him again, ‘You are Osama bin Laden,” his mother remembered. “You are a terrorist. Your mom is a terrorist. Your dad is a terrorist. You have to go back to your country.”
His mother learned of the incident after a teacher called the family’s home to report it.”
…“but in this instance, police found the two students meant it as a joke.” Boys will be boys, after all. Not only that…“On Wednesday night, no one answered the phone at the home of the boy who wrote about Mustafa in the yearbook”…we are products of our environment.
17 Comments
