Police Presence in 27 Toronto Schools: Will It Work?
Thursday, September 11th, 2008Jordan Manners was five days beyond his fifteenth birthday when he died on May 23, 2007 in the hallway of C.W. Jefferys C.I. Secondary School (”C.W. Jefferys”) as a result of a bullet wound to the chest. The students of C.W. Jefferys honour his memory with a tribute that remains in the main hall of the school entitled “One Bullet Wounds Many”.
It was recently announced that 27 Toronto-area schools will have a permanent armed Police presence within their halls. This news might seem to prompt alarm to those in the public unawares of the rising violent crime committed in Toronto schools, nor of the rising rates of gun carriage despite efforts by both the Provincial Government in Ontario and the Toronto Police Force to stem its tide for well over a decade.
It’s part of what the Toronto District School Board calls a school resource officer initiative and is a result of last year’s Falconer report on school violence. Following its release, the board said it would draft a plan to increase safety in schools.
[...]
Toronto police already visit local schools, but under the new plan, police would have a dedicated space within the schools.
“Our goal is to make our schools safe,” said Toronto police Chief William Blair in a statement.
But will it actually work? The get tough measures come as a result of The Road to Health, A Final Report on School Safety, known as the Falconer report after the investigation panel’s chair, lawyer Julian Falconer (also on Maher Arar’s legal team).
The report reveals systemic gender violence against young women, uncovering the gang-rape of a young Muslim woman at Manners’ school. It also reports systemic violence against youth of colour, and found that one-third of students at Toronto’s aboriginal school are suspended. The picture of students as “walking wounded” has startled many.
The report’s main conclusion places blame on the school system’s “culture of silence” - yet Falconer also wrote in the report that the majority of students feel safe at school, regardless of the rise in violent crime. This would suggest that factions and cliques within school populations have been marginalized and are disconnected in more significant ways from school life, and are being drawn towards community-based violence which is more significantly on the rise in the communities in which the schools reside in.
Media reports have focused on the suggested remedies in the report; the requirement of school uniforms, police and “sniffer dogs” in schools, and other such measures. But is the TDSC capable of implementing everything expediently? The report suggests its not.
In its conclusion, the report states that “Government policy from the mid 1990’s into amalgamation emphasized cost-saving measures intended to dismantle key support structures for marginalized communities.” It continues and notes that the school board is presently “nowhere near sufficiently funded to manage” the diverse students it serves, and can’t provide enough social workers, hallway monitors or child and youth workers.
For most community-based plans which include a rise in policing, greater and more specific social programs and community involvement are needed in conjunction to make things work. In the case of school safety in urban communities, it really comes down to the degree to which a community works together to harmonize itself and find a common issue it can galvanize around. The safety of its children is a strong one to do just that, yet if the proper funding is not present to enable them to do so, having permanent police presences in schools may only limit the rates in which violence inside the schools occurs— having little to no impact on the rates and means by which it happens within the greater communities outside its walls.


When you have the body of work as an artist that Matt does, there’s two forms of death you need to avoid: the first is the death that happens when you stop growing and repeat your past work, regurgitating it, sometimes unknowingly (that’s the worst kind). The second is the death that happens when you think you might revive your career by ripping off the latest music trends…“Ladies and Gentlemen, The MattyGoods and their hit single Mr. Feelbad.”
Updated: Some video footage of what happened, here: